BCAS President CA Manish Sampat's Message for the Month of January 2020

        Dear Members,

Wishing you and your loved ones a very Happy, Healthy and Prosperous New Year!

It’s New Year, friends! As the New Year stands before us, it’s another 366 days of opportunities and reasons to be happy. It’s like a new chapter waiting to be written in the book called LIFE. So let’s all of us resolve to seize this opportunity and promise ourselves that we will strive towards happiness and make this world a better place to live in for ourselves and others around us.

I hope 2020 will mark the beginning of a new decade of hope, trust and well-being of our profession. As I communicate with you for the first time at the beginning of this decade, I would like to emphasise certain recent developments in our profession that will have a great impact on the way we discharge our professional responsibilities and obligations.

ICAI Code of Ethics: The Code of Ethics issued by the ICAI was aligned with the International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA) Code of Ethics 2005 for the first time in 2009. Now, after a gap of ten years, the ICAI has decided to revise the Code of Ethics applicable to the profession with effect from 1st April, 2020. As in the case of the code issued in 2009, this edition, too, is divided into two parts, Part A representing provisions of the IESBA Code of Ethics as suitably incorporated after modification, and Part B representing the domestic provisions of India governing the Chartered Accountants’ Act, 1949.

Part A of the Code of Ethics was revised in 2018 on the basis of the IESBA Code of Ethics, 2018 edition; and now the ICAI has proposed a revision of Part B of the Code of Ethics, 2019.

Since the past decade (when this code was last revised), multiple changes have taken place in the domestic rules and regulations governing our profession. Changes in the CA Act, 1949, ICAI Council guidelines and decisions and clarifications of the Ethical Standards Board have been incorporated in the new code. Further, other developments and contemporary requirements like New Companies Act, 2013, revision of Accounting Standards (AS) and Standards of Auditing (SA) also mandated compilatory updating and upgrading Part B of the code.

Various new provisions, clauses, sections have been proposed to be inserted in Part B such as: Responding to Non-Compliance of Laws and Regulations; provision of taxation services to the audit clients; prohibition on management responsibilities to the audit clients; restrictions on total fees from a client; duty of accountant in case of breach of Independence Standards; advertisement guidelines; guidelines on website and social networking sites; affiliations with networks; long association with firms and so on.

The ICAI will carry out mass awareness and educational programmes but it is important for us to be aware of the changes to maintain the inclusive and ethical culture of our profession and ensure that none of us is caught unaware of these changes.

Report on Audit Quality Review (2018-19): Cases of financial irregularities continue to haunt the corporate world, both domestically and internationally, bringing to the forefront concerns on the need to improve the quality of audit services carried out by auditors. Last year, the Financial Reporting Council of the UK expressed concern over falling audit quality and partly attributed this deterioration to a failure to challenge management and show appropriate professional scepticism. So far, the Quality Review Board (QRB) of ICAI has being carrying out reviews of listed and other public interest entities and issuing a report on the observations from the Audit Quality Review carried out by them annually. This report of the QRB for reviews carried out during financial year 2018-19 was issued in October, 2019. It highlights the key findings and observations from reviews carried out on audit quality of 51 entities (which included 51 audit firms, 64 audit files and 22 industries) indicating the QRB’s approach, key trends, their expectations and other focus areas.

Though the reported observations are from reviews carried out on the said 51 entities, these deficiencies can act as check-points for others to improve their audit quality. The report highlights in detail non-compliance of SA, AS (standard wise) and other relevant regulatory requirements. Out of the total observations, 66% required improvements, 33% were generally acceptable and 1% required significant improvement. I am sure this will make for interesting reading and help in improving the quality of audit services rendered by us.

Audit Quality Review (AQR) by NFRA: More recently, the NFRA carried out its first AQR on the statutory audit of IL&FS Financial Services Limited for F.Y. 2017-18. NFRA has verified the compliance of SA, assessing the audit quality control system of the audit firm and the extent to which the same was complied with in the performance of the audit. This report has made some startling observations and comments on the compliance of independence requirements, role of engagement partner, communication with those charged with governance, evaluation of risk of material misstatement, management’s written representations, evaluation of going concern assumptions and documentation of the audit quality control system. A reading of this report will also go a long way in overall improvement in the quality of services rendered by us.

‘Professionalism: It’s NOT the job you DO, It’s HOW you DO the job.’

Do write to me at president@bcasonline.org

Yours truly

CA. Manish Sampat









Site Address & Location

Bombay Chartered Accountants' Society
7, Jolly Bhavan 2, Ground Floor, New Marine Lines, Mumbai - 400020
Join Us: